Chapter 2

Tax Implications When Buying a Rental Property

Discover key tax implications when buying a rental property, from income tax to deductions, depreciation, and 1031 exchanges. Maximize returns with smart strategies.

Ben Luxon

Head of Content, Landlord Studio

Tax Implications When Buying a Rental Property
Up next:  
Chapter 3

When it comes to understanding the tax implications of buying and owning a rental property, landlords should, at a minimum, familiarize themselves with how rental income is taxed, the nature of deductible expenses and depreciation, and the intricacies of capital gains and 1031 exchanges

Having a solid understanding of these elements can significantly influence your financial strategy and enhance your overall investment returns.

That’s why we’ve created this article—to provide comprehensive insights into everything aspiring property owners need to know about rental taxes, from the tax benefits of rental property to real estate tax deductions. 

Rental Income Is Taxed As Normal Income

The IRS categorizes rental income as normal income, meaning it is subject to both federal and state income taxes. 

It's important to note that landlords need to report not just their rental income but all income received through their rental business, this includes regular rent payments, advance rent, lease cancellation payments, security deposit deductions, and even expenses covered by tenants.

How Does the IRS Detect Rental Income?

If you've recently rented out your property you might be wondering, "How does the IRS know I have rental income?", especially if you're collecting rent payments in cash. The answer to that question is more complex than you might imagine.

The IRS employs several strategies to ensure real estate investors are reporting all of their rental income. And whilst you might be able to fly under the radar for a while, not reporting or innaccurately reporting your rental income is very likely to raise a red flag with the IRS audit office.

Here are some key methods the IRS uses to determine if an investor has rental income:

  • Routine Audits: While the chances of being audited are relatively low, higher-income earners often attract more scrutiny. Certain behaviors, such as failing to report all taxable income or claiming unusually high deductions, can trigger an audit.
  • Automated Underreporter Program: This program identifies discrepancies between the income reported on tax returns and the information provided by third parties, such as banks or payment processors. If rental income is overlooked, the IRS may uncover it through these reports.
  • Public Records and Paperwork: Various records related to rental properties can alert the IRS to unreported income. For instance, licenses required for collecting rental taxes or mortgage interest statements (Form 1098) can be cross-referenced with tax returns.
  • Whistleblower Claims: If someone reports a landlord for underreporting rental income, the IRS may investigate further. The Whistleblower Office even offers monetary rewards for information that leads to successful tax collection.

You Might Also Like: Top 7 IRS Audit Triggers Real Estate Investors Need to Know

Penalties for Failing to Declare Rental Income

Neglecting to report your rental income can lead to significant penalties from the IRS. These may include:

  • Accuracy-Related Penalty: This penalty can reach up to 20% of the understated tax due if the IRS determines that income was intentionally or negligently omitted.
  • Civil Fraud Penalty: In cases of fraud—where a taxpayer knowingly fails to report income—the penalty can be as high as 75% of the unpaid tax.
  • Criminal Charges: Although rare, criminal charges may be pursued in cases of egregious tax evasion or filing false returns.

The Tax Benefits and Costs of Purchasing a Rental Property

Aside from the taxes and other costs that come with buying a rental property, there are several benefits that it offers. For example, you can qualify for certain tax deductions that help reduce your overall tax liability. 

Below is an overview of some of the key tax benefits and costs involved in owning rental properties.

Tax Benefits of Owning Rental Properties

Deductible Operating Expenses

Many operating expenses necessary for managing and maintaining a rental property are generally tax-deductible. These can include:

  • Advertising costs
  • Property management fees
  • Repairs and maintenance
  • Utilities paid directly by the landlord
  • Insurance premiums, including homeowner and landlord liability insurance

Get a complete list of all your rental property tax deductible expenses here

How To Leverage Rental Accounting Software To Maximize Your Deductions

In order to run a profitable rental business, it is essential to track and claim every possible tax deduction. To get started, log back in or create your free Landlord Studio account today.

Using Landlord Studio, there are several ways to create a rental property expense: manually entering expenses or reconciling via the bank feeds feature. Follow the steps below.


Method 1: Add Expenses Manually

Step 1: Open the mobile app.
Step 2: Use the quick action button and select ‘Add Expense’.
Step 3: Select the property the expense is for.
Step 4: Either manually enter the expense details or tap on the camera icon in the top right.
Step 5: Take a picture of your receipt. The software will read the receipt details and enter them for you.
Step 6: Select an expense category and add any additional notes.
Step 7: Hit Save.


Method 2: Use Bank Feeds

Step 1: Log in on desktop or open the app.
Step 2: Navigate to "Bank Feeds" via the left-hand menu (or bottom menu bar on mobile).
Step 3: If you haven’t already, connect your bank accounts. This will automatically import up to two years of data. If already connected, proceed to the next step.
Step 4: Select the relevant transaction, add the property and category details, and hit Save. This will create a new expense in the system.
Note: If you’ve already added the expense manually, the system will automatically match the existing expense with the bank feed transaction, allowing one-click reconciliation. To make reconciliation faster, create custom bank rules.


Log back in or create your free Landlord Studio account today and generate a free Schedule E report. Make tax time easy with software designed for you.

Mortgage Interest Deduction

The interest paid on a mortgage for a rental property is fully deductible, which can substantially lower your taxable income. This deduction also applies to interest on loans used for property improvements or related business expenses.

Depreciation Deduction

Real estate investors can depreciate their rental properties over 27.5 years, allowing them to recover costs associated with wear and tear. For example, if you purchase a property for $150,000 (excluding land value), you would be able to deduct approximately $5,454 each year in depreciations.

Deferral of Capital Gains Tax

Utilizing a Section 1031 exchange allows investors to defer capital gains taxes when selling one rental property to purchase another of equal or greater value. This strategy enables you to reinvest your profits without facing immediate tax consequences.

Deductible Owner Expenses

Even if you hire a property manager, you can still deduct certain owner-related expenses. These may include continuing education costs related to real estate, travel expenses for business purposes, and home office deductions if applicable.

Avoidance of FICA Taxes

Income generated from rental properties is typically not classified as earned income, meaning it is exempt from FICA taxes (Social Security and Medicare taxes). This distinction can lead to substantial savings compared to income from traditional employment.

Pass-Through Deduction

If your rental business qualifies as a pass-through entity (such as an LLC or S corporation), you may be eligible to deduct up to 20% of your net business income from your taxable income, subject to specific limits. This is one of the notable tax benefits of rental property ownership.

Costs Associated with Owning Rental Property

While there are numerous tax benefits associated with owning rental properties, it’s also important to consider the costs involved:

  • Property Management Fees: Hiring a property management company can cut into your profits.
  • Maintenance and Repairs: Regular upkeep is essential for maintaining the property's condition, which can be costly.
  • Property Taxes: Property taxes vary by state and property value but are a big annual expense in some locations.
  • Insurance Costs: Adequate landlord insurance coverage is crucial but adds to your overall expenses.
  • Potential Vacancy Losses: Vacancy periods can lead to lost rental income while still incurring costs such as mortgage payments and utilities.

When assessing a potential investment it is essential that you take a balanced view of the finances to ensure the property produces the cash flow you need for it to make sense as an investment. 

Understanding Depreciation on Newly Acquired Properties

Depreciation allows property owners to deduct a portion of the property's cost from their taxable income each year, reflecting the gradual wear and tear on the property. 

According to IRS guidelines, residential rental properties can be depreciated over 27.5 years, while commercial properties typically follow a 39-year depreciation schedule. This means landlords can write off a consistent annual amount based on the property's depreciable basis, which excludes the value of the land since the land itself does not depreciate.

Depreciation on rental property can start as soon as the property is ‘placed in service’. A property is generally considered ‘placed in service’ when you start looking for your first tenant - i.e. you create and publish the listing online. 

The ‘placed in service’ date is also important when tracking expenses, as any repairs undertaken before the property is placed in service are deemed ‘improvements’ by the IRS and needed to be added to the property ‘cost basis’ and depreciated - meaning they cannot be deducted in full in that year. 

Depreciation is a non-cash expense which means it does not impact actual cash flow; it merely provides a tax benefit that enhances financial performance. 

Finally, it’s important to also understand depreciation recapture. This is the process by which the IRS will reclaim some of the depreciated value should you sell the property at a later date. The IRS will claim the depreciation recapture value whether or not you claim depreciation, so make sure you do.  

Tax-Impacted Choices: Financing, Location, and Property Type

When it comes to real estate investment, the interplay of property location, financing options, and property types significantly influences tax obligations and benefits for landlords. By understanding these factors, investors can make informed decisions that optimize their financial outcomes.

Property Location

The location of a property is a critical determinant of its tax obligations. Different states and municipalities impose varying tax rates and assessment practices, leading to significant disparities in property taxes. 

For example, urban areas typically feature higher property values, which results in elevated tax rates compared to rural locations. Additionally, local government services funded by property taxes—such as schools, police, and infrastructure—vary greatly depending on the needs and resources of the area. 

Consequently, a property situated in a high-demand urban center may incur higher taxes than a similar property in a less desirable location, ultimately affecting overall investment returns.

Financing Options

Financing choices also play a pivotal role in shaping tax implications for property owners. For example, if a landlord finances their properties through mortgages, they often benefit from the ability to deduct mortgage interest from their taxable income. 

Other financing structures such as conventional loans and government-backed loans also provide different advantages and disadvantages concerning tax treatment.

Furthermore, it's important to note that the choice of business entity for property ownership further impacts tax liabilities. For instance, owning properties through a Limited Liability Company (LLC) can provide pass-through taxation benefits, potentially lowering overall tax burdens compared to personal ownership.

Property Types: Single-Family vs. Multifamily

Finally, the type of property also significantly influences tax obligations. Single-family homes are often assessed differently than multifamily units, such as apartment buildings. Typically, single-family homes enjoy lower property tax rates and may qualify for various homeowner exemptions that reduce their taxable value. 

In contrast, multifamily properties might face higher assessments due to their income-generating potential. Additionally, multifamily properties offer substantial deductions through depreciation. 

Landlords can depreciate the building's value over time while offsetting rental income with expenses related to maintenance and management. This depreciation is particularly advantageous for investors seeking to maximize cash flow and minimize taxable income while reaping the tax benefits of rental property.

Rental Property Expense Tracking with Landlord Studio

Looking for an easier way to report and file your rental taxes? Landlord Studio is an invaluable tool for landlords seeking to streamline their expense tracking and maximize tax benefits. 

The smart receipt scanning feature simplifies the documentation process by digitizing receipts and automatically inputting details. You can also create recurring expenses for routine overheads, such as mortgage and insurance payments, saving you time and ensuring consistent expense tracking. 

Landlord Studio makes it easy for you to track your income and expenses on a property-by-property basis, which is essential when filing your Schedule E at tax time and comes with default expense categories in line with IRS requirements making it super easy to get started.

The integration with bank feeds automates income and expense tracking, while built-in mileage tracker helps landlords maximize travel deductions.

And at tax time, instantly generate any of over 20+ customizable reports with the click of a button.

Keeping up with rental taxes doesn't have to be stressful. Create your free Landlord Studio account and discover how it can transform your property management and accounting.